Orleans Town Manager, Chiefs Get Strong Reviews

by Ryan Bray
Orleans Police Chief Scott MacDonald, Town Manager Kim Newman and Fire Chief Geof Deering each received strong performance reviews from the select board earlier this month. COURTESY PHOTO Orleans Police Chief Scott MacDonald, Town Manager Kim Newman and Fire Chief Geof Deering each received strong performance reviews from the select board earlier this month. COURTESY PHOTO

ORLEANS – Kim Newman continues to have the overwhelming support of the select board.
The board gave the town manager an overall score of 4.8 out of 5 in her annual performance review, which was discussed at the board’s Nov. 4 meeting. The board also gave high marks in their annual evaluations for Police Chief Scott MacDonald and Fire Chief Geof Deering.
Newman’s impact on the town has been strongly felt since she started work in July 2023. That has included hiring new personnel and department heads and making headway on longstanding town initiatives, namely the siting and construction of a new fire station on Eldredge Park Way.
The select board evaluated Newman’s performance across six categories, including board support and relations (4.6), financial management (4.7), personnel management and organizational leadership (4.8), community leadership and public relations (4.8), town operations and infrastructure (4.8) and personal and professional individual qualities and professional skills and status (4.8).
“To receive a 4.8 out of 5 overall with the highest marks in personnel and organizational leadership and town leadership is an honor,” Newman told the board. “But I want to be clear about something. Those scores belong to our staff. They reflect the outstanding department heads and employees who show up everyday for this town.”
Newman specifically noted the efforts that have been made to improve the town’s communication and public outreach. Those efforts, she said, have helped support Orleans’ already engaged and active citizenry.
“Everything reflected in these scores begins with a community that is engaged and cares deeply about this town,” she said. “It’s a privilege to serve as your manager. We work really hard.”
Looking ahead, the board tasked Newman with continuing the “great work on succession planning and employee engagement,” making continued headway on developing and implementing “important technology procedures and practices” and making more progress on “bond rating implications and long-term debt/capital planning.” 
Both MacDonald and Deering earned an overall score of 4.9 out of 5 from the board. Both were evaluated in the areas of individual characteristics, professional skills and status, relations with members of the elected body, policy execution, reporting, citizen relations, staffing, supervision, fiscal management and community.
“Working in this community has been a privilege,” said MacDonald, who has served as chief in Orleans since 2012. “After all these years, I wake up everyday and still enjoy coming to work. And I think that speaks to the community we serve here in Orleans.”
MacDonald, who has been in law enforcement for 35 years, said his primary goal in the coming years is to continue to develop what he called the department’s group of “talented young officers,” and to also develop a plan for transitioning the department over to new leadership.
“I have a few years left, and my goal is that the next leadership team for this community comes from within the organization,’ he said.
The board in its review also asked MacDonald to “prioritize mental health initiatives” both for the department and the broader community, conduct “proactive research of best practices nationally regarding policies on noise, animal control, parking environmental initiatives, etc., and behavioral change of volunteer enforcement,” and to continue his “great mentorship” within the department.
Deering joined the Orleans Fire Department in 2001 and has served as chief since 2020. He thanked the select board, Newman, fire department staff and members of the community for their continued support during his tenure as chief.
“I’m so blessed to have 25 years so far with this fire department, and I intend to stay a few more,” he said, noting that he is looking forward to seeing construction of the new fire station through to completion.
The board asked Deering to focus on “succession planning” and continued development of fire department employees, and to keep the existing functional service needs of the department “top of mind” as the department prepares to transition over to the new station.
After summarizing the reviews, Select board member Kevin Galligan asked if members of the board should be held to a similar review process by the public.
“No one really does that of us,” he said. “I always leave meetings thinking ‘How did that meeting go? Could it be done better?’ But all we get is an election every three years.”
“I think that’s a good point,” board member Michael Herman said.
Newman said the matter could be itemized on a future agenda for discussion.
Email Ryan Bray at ryan@capecodchronicle.com