Voters Deny Nauset Estuary Petition
ORLEANS – Voters at Monday night’s special town meeting opted against supporting a citizens’ petition seeking to advance efforts to protect the polluted Nauset Estuary.
The petition from residents Charlie Carlson, William Brotherton and Bill Amaru sought to spur action toward establishing a total maximum daily load (TMDL) target for the estuary, which would determine how much nitrogen the waterway could safely accommodate and how much would need to be removed from the water annually.
The petitioners said approval of the petition, which appeared as the final article on the fall warrant, is needed due to the town’s failure to make headway on cleaning up the estuary. The town entered into an intermunicipal agreement with the town of Eastham in 2023 in which the two towns vouched to work together toward a watershed permit for the estuary, but the petitioners said little work has been done to achieve that goal.
“Instead, Orleans officials have opposed action,” Carlson said in presenting the petition Monday night.
Carlson presented a motion amending several aspects of the article as it appeared in the warrant. That included lowering the amount of free cash sought from $300,000 to $200,000 to pay for “part” of Mass DEP and the Environmental Protection Agency’s cost for establishing a TMDL for the estuary, including Mill Pond. The funding also would be used to pay for any additional costs incurred by the town in assisting in the effort.
The motion also stipulated that the $200,000 would come back to the town should the state and/or EPA fail to provide supplemental funding in support of establishing a TMDL by Dec. 31, 2030.
The motion also asked voters to ask that the select board make a request in writing to “the appropriate authorities” that the state and EPA work toward establishing TMDL standards for the estuary “as soon as reasonably possible,” preferably by Dec. 31, 2030, and involve Eastham in that process as deemed appropriate.
Carlson said the motion to amend the petition came after conferring with the town’s legal counsel.
“We believe this motion addresses all of town counsel’s concerns,” he said.
The select board in September unanimously voted against recommending approval of the petition. Instead, it voiced support for sticking to the town’s existing wastewater management plan for Pleasant Bay. The plan, which calls for 16 total phases of sewering through 2067, calls for the estuary to be sewered in phase 11, which is at least 24 years away.
Specifically, the board is concerned that establishing separate TMDL standards for the estuary will interfere with the wastewater plan as currently laid out.
“We have a plan. It’s working. Let’s stick with it,” said Kevin Galligan of the select board.
Galligan took issue with the suggestion that the town and Eastham have failed to act to protect the estuary. Eastham is in the process of starting its own $170 million sewering project, he said. Ongoing sewering in Orleans has served to reduce the amount of nitrogen flowing into the estuary, he added.
Alan McClennen, who was instrumental in helping craft the wastewater management plan and helped see through the planning and construction of the town’s wastewater treatment plant, also spoke against the petition. He said when the town expanded sewering from six phases to 16 to reduce per-phase costs in 2024, the state gave the town an estimated TMDL target, but advised against seeking one for the estuary.
“Instead, it recommended that Orleans and Eastham continue the work they are already doing to meet the estimated TMDL,” he said. McClennen added that a permeable reactive barrier in place at Nauset Regional Middle School is also helping to keep nitrogen out of the estuary.
Tony Pearl and Elaine Baird of the finance committee also weighed in on the petition. Pearl spoke in support, arguing that passing the petition will “allow the state to make Nauset Estuary a priority.” But Baird, while acknowledging the need to improve the estuary’s water quality, raised concern with the financial implications of disrupting the phasing of the town’s existing wastewater plan.
“If we start to change those phases, then we’re going to start doubling up those amounts of money,” she said.
Scott Zenke lamented the existing condition of Mill Pond, calling it “dead.” He said the town needs the “science” around Mill Pond and the estuary that the petition is designed to help gather.
Others, including Andrew Burling, called support for the petition a “no risk proposition,” especially given that the money would be returned to the town if the state and EPA fail to act. He said while the town has a wastewater plan in place, it also needs to be flexible.
“If you don’t adapt and change to changing conditions, it’s a pretty sad state of affairs,” he said.
Josh Stewart said that in northwest Orleans near Rock Harbor, residents are “asked to bear the burden of much of Orleans’ future,” be it the development of new housing or the town’s ongoing wastewater efforts.
“We literally get your effluent put into our Cape Cod Bay in front of Rock Harbor,” he said. “So the least you can do is allow us a little baseline science. It’s tough not to sit and wonder what you’re afraid of.”
Amaru said voters should support the petition, noting that the factors impacting the estuary’s water quality are largely human-driven. That includes the use of fertilizers and herbicides that find their way into the water as well as stormwater runoff driven in part by local traffic.
“We are responsible for what’s happened to the estuary, and we will be the ones to decide if it gets fixed,” he said.
But others Monday night objected to the idea of the estuary jumping the queue of other areas of town currently scheduled for sewering ahead of it.
“This petition just seems to smack of entitlement,” said Doug Fromm. “I want what I want when I want it, and the devil with the rest.”
After the question was called, voters denied the petition 282 to 174.
“I’m disappointed, partly because I think a lot of the information that was supplied earlier in the public comment period simply wasn't true,” Amaru said following the meeting. “People were pulling things out of the ether.”
But the vote against the petition should not be accepted by the select board as a vote for “inaction,” said Tom Coleman, president of the Orleans Pond Coalition.
“If Nauset Estuary is not getting the attention it deserves, OPC will be among the first organizations in town to say so,” he said.
Elsewhere on the warrant, voters approved the reappropriation of $501,089.86 for a backup generator for the council on aging through Article17. A request to use $100,000 in water stabilization fund to conduct a nitrogen attenuation study in the Pochet Marsh also was approved. Voters approved rescinding $575,000 in authorized but unused funds through the passage of Article 12.
Article 19, which sought $450,000 in free cash for use in "planning, consulting, design, engineering, construction, renovation and related capital improvements" at 44 Main St., was indefinitely postponed.
For additional town meeting coverage, see this week's Town Hall Action column on Page 6.
Email Ryan Bray at ryan@capecodchronicle.com
A healthy Barnstable County requires great community news.
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Loading...