‘He Saw The Magic:’ Monument Honors Brewster Naturalist John Hay

by Andy Kirkaldy

BREWSTER – On Monday, the Cape Cod Museum of Natural History unveiled a granite monument in memory of the late John Hay, a longtime town resident, conservationist and nature author who helped found the Brewster institution in 1954. 
On a sunny morning, Hay’s daughter, Kitty Hay, pulled a cloth cover off the two-sided monument in front of about three dozen museum supporters and staff members gathered for the event.
Hay was the last of several speakers who recalled and honored John Hay. She talked about her father’s adventurous side in connecting her with nature, such as taking her outside to their Dry Hill home’s porch to watch lightning storms or to Nauset Beach to experience a hurricane firsthand.
“He just saw the magic,” Hay said. “There’s so much magic out there, and I was so fortunate to have this incredible father, and I’m just so grateful there’s going to be a monument for him.”
Hay capped the event by uncovering the five-foot-tall monument that on the side facing Route 6A features a stoneware sculpture by local artist Steve Kemp that depicts swarming alewives. Underneath the sculpture is displayed a quote from Hay’s 1959 book ‘The Run’: “Every time the alewives return…I ask them where they have been.”
The other side of a monument shows an image of Hay pitching a tent above an inscription that reads: “John Hay, 8/31/1915-2/26/2011, Naturalist & Writer, Cofounder of the Cape Cod Museum of Natural History.”
Hay’s former Dry Hill home is now the headquarters of the Brewster Conservation Trust. Hay wrote 18 books, and according to a Cape Cod Museum of Natural History press release, the Boston Globe “described his literary work as belonging ‘in the company of Thoreau, Donald Culross Peattie, Henry Beston, and Rachel Carson.’”
On Monday others spoke about Hay and recalled the history of the museum, which now occupies 17,000 square feet at 869 Main St. (Route 6A) after more humble beginnings.
Museum curator and digital narrator Kate Roderick expanded on the institution’s history. Hay was a driving force among a group of Brewster parents who in 1954 came together to offer education in the natural world. They based their effort in a room in what was then Brewster Town Hall and is now the council on aging building. 
The group later started meeting in a tent on what is now the museum property, and with generous support from the community over the years the tent became a building, the museum bought the land on which it stood, another building was erected, and additions came along in the 1960s, 1970s,1980s and 2010 to include what the museum now offers, including aquariums, displays on Wampanoag and other Indigenous Peoples’ relationships with the natural world and much more. Information is available at ccmnh.org. 
Hay’s outlook on the importance of the natural world for humanity has informed the museum during its entire existence, according to Museum Executive Director Dr. Stephen Uzzo.
“Hay’s philosophy that humanity is a part of nature, not just an observer, has run through our museum’s DNA for all of its nearly 75 years,” Uzzo said in the museum press release. 
Among the speakers on Monday were museum board chair Raymond Herbert, who described how Hay’s books and advocacy had influenced him personally and his readership more broadly, and former longtime museum archaeologist Fred Dunford, who praised Hay for bringing archaeology to the museum as a vital component. 
David Gessner, who in 2005 wrote “The Prophet of Dry Hill” after spending the better part of a year in close contact with Hay, said, “There was something both formal and warm about his voice.”
Gessner recalled Hay seeing surveyor stakes while the two walked along a beach watching birds. “The flags of doom,” he recalled Hay saying. Gessner concluded from this and other interactions that Hay “was well aware what was happening (overdevelopment) on the Cape.”
Gessner also focused on his learning about what he called Hay’s “biocentric” outlook on existence, one that looked at life that focused outward on nature rather than inward through the lens of mankind.
Gessner said he was originally reluctant to call Hay a prophet, but changed his mind. 
“Here’s a man who had a vision, and spent his life trying to articulate his vision,” he said. “Part of that vision was trying to convince people the things they value are not the things of greatest value, that a whole secret life is available to them if they reorder their priorities.”
Gessner said of Hay’s outlook, “Human beings are not so central to the world after all… If what truly matters is respecting the Earth and observing the diversity of eco-systems, then it follows the traditional ways of seeing land as for what one can get needs to be discarded. These ideas are, of course, antithetical to a culture that always keeps half an eye cocked toward a mirror.”
What answer does Gessner say Hay suggested?
“For 50 years John insisted we should not be looking in the mirror, but out and through the window,” he said. “Ultimately, if we follow our better instincts, we can climb through the window, and there, outside of ourselves, we will find things that will expand ourselves… Unlike most of us, John spent his life training himself to look outward.”