Cape League Adds Five New Members To Hall Of Fame In 25th Induction Class
EAST HARWICH – The Cape Cod Baseball League added five individuals to its Hall of Fame last weekend, a group that included four All-League players from the 1990s and 2000s and a former executive instrumental in expanding Cape baseball’s reach and visibility.
The new Hall of Famers — Grant Green (Yarmouth-Dennis/Chatham, 2007-08), Matt Goyen (Brewster, 2004), Seth Etherton (Chatham, 1995-96), Kevin Nicholson (Wareham, 1996) and John Garner — were inducted Sunday at the Wequassett Inn and Resort in Harwich during a ceremony that recognized their contributions to the bat-and-ball game played on the salty spit of sand in the Atlantic Ocean.
The group accounted for several awards/honors and a host of distinguished statistics between their seasons. Combined, they played 189 games in Major League Baseball. It was the Cape League’s 25th induction class.
“Looking at it now, the Cape has meant so much more,” said Green. “It's one of the true places that I think, without us ever even knowing as young kids, it molds us into who we become.”
Green, a shortstop from USC, won a championship with Yarmouth-Dennis in 2007, hitting .291 with four home runs.
He returned to the Cape in 2008 to play for Chatham. He hit .348 with 12 doubles, six home runs and 21 runs batted in. The campaign included a two-run homer (and Most Valuable Player award) in the All-Star Game and ended with a Robert A. McNeece Award for Outstanding Pro Prospect.
The Oakland Athletics drafted Green 13th overall in 2009. He also played for the Los Angeles Angels, San Francisco Giants and Washington Nationals as a utility player from 2013 to 2017.
Green said he had never realized “how much of a community the Cape was.”
“It's where true baseball is, and I was just lucky enough to spend a couple summers here,” he said.
Goyen came to Brewster in 2004 as a left-handed pitcher from Division II Georgia College. He actually was supposed to have played for Chatham in 2003, but he dislocated his ankle and broke his leg during a play early that preceding collegiate season.
He said he felt like, whether it was true or not, his performance with Brewster would impact future opportunities for small school players.
“Stepping on the Cape that summer, I knew people had stuck their necks out to give me this opportunity,” he said.
Goyen proceeded to win the Benjamin F.C. Whitehouse Award for Outstanding Pitcher by leading the league in strikeouts (80). He threw 57 innings to a 1.25 earned run average.
The Florida Marlins selected him 96th overall in the 2005 MLB Draft.
“Less to prove I belonged, my motivation that summer was to prove that the folks that had believed in me were right,” Goyen said. “The summer of 2004 was incredible. We had an unbelievable group of coaches and players in Brewster, and everything clicked.”
John Garner, a Maine native, contributed to the Cape League through various roles for more than 25 years. He served as the league’s first broadcast and public relations director. He was named Executive of the Year in 2014.
Former president Judy Walden Scarafile said Garner “almost single-handedly created the broadcast department for the Cape League” and “single-handedly brought TV to the Cape League.”
“Without a doubt, John created the very building blocks that enabled the league to take broadcasting and publicity to a level that the league never ever imagined,” she said.
Garner produced reports on 99.9 WQRC and 95.1 WXTK, and he worked as the color commentator for Cape League Games of the Week on 96.3 WEEI and WBZ.com.
“The Cape League has grown by leaps and bounds over 30 years under John's leadership in PR and broadcasting, and we're very grateful for all that John Garner is,” Scarafile said.
Nicholson, a switch-hitting shortstop out of Stetson, won the Pat Sorenti Most Valuable Player Award with the Wareham Gatemen in 1996.
He racked up 18 doubles (tied for second all-time in a single season) while similarly leading the league in total bases (76) and extra base hits (22). He hit .315 with three home runs, a .510 slugging percentage and 23 runs batted in.
Nicholson, who’s from British Columbia, was also named Most Valuable Player of the West Division in that summer’s All-Star Game.
“It gave us a chance to meet new teammates, get exposed to new coaching, a different point of view, different eyes on you, and that really had huge impacts on our lives,” he said.
The San Diego Padres drafted Nicholson 27th overall in 1997. He appeared in 37 MLB games and played for the Canadian national team.
“There's nothing like it,” he said. “Even being a Canadian playing America's national pastime, I think I truly understood the importance of this league and the opportunity that it gave us to showcase ourselves on this stage, so I'm very grateful for that.”
Etherton, a right-handed pitcher from USC, posted two standout seasons for Chatham in 1995 and 1996.
That first year, he pitched 49 innings to a 1.29 earned run average with 65 strikeouts. The next summer, he had a 1.98 earned run average, striking out 68 across 50 innings.
“You learn so much, and you're mixed in with so many different people from all over the country, the best of the best, and that's what's so magical about it,” he said.
Etherton won the 1998 College World Series and was drafted 18th overall that same year by the Anaheim Angels. He additionally played for the Cincinnati Reds, Athletics and Kansas City Royals. He logged more than 100 big league innings in parts of four seasons from 2000 to 2006.
Baseball is a game that “will beat you up” and “kick you a little bit,” said Etherton, who, upon being claimed by the New York Yankees in 2002 after shoulder surgery, was told by a team doctor he’d never pitch again.
“The life and moving around through pro ball and just all these things and the coaching, it really has been amazing,” he said. “It's been a very bumpy road with just spurts of just amazingness, and there's things in this life that you learn.”
A healthy Barnstable County requires great community news.
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Please support The Cape Cod Chronicle by subscribing today!
Loading...